Building an appetite for DEIB,
one breath at a time

A leader in a suit sits at a round table with a yellow checkmark thought bubble indicating they think everything is fine, while surrounding employees have thought bubbles with a tangled scribble of stress and ellipses of unspoken concerns, illustrating a lack of psychological safety.

The Role of Leaders in Creating Psychological Safety: Beyond the Open-Door Policy

, 8 mins read

A team meeting ends with everyone seemingly on the same page. No one raises an objection, questions the approach, or points out a potential problem. The leader walks away believing the team is aligned and a decision has been reached. Yet once the meeting ends, some team members share their concerns privately. This gap between apparent agreement and what employees actually think is worth paying attention to.

In many organisations, open communication and honest feedback are encouraged, but the everyday experience of employees may tell a different story. The way a leader responds to disagreement, handles mistakes or receives uncomfortable feedback can influence whether people choose to speak openly or hold back.

This is where psychological safety becomes important. It allows employees to express different viewpoints, ask for help, acknowledge mistakes and challenge existing ways of working without fear of embarrassment or negative consequences. Leaders play an important role in shaping these experiences through their everyday actions and interactions with their teams.

What Is Psychological Safety in the Workplace?

Psychological safety refers to a shared belief among team members that they can express themselves, ask questions, admit mistakes and take interpersonal risks without fear of embarrassment, rejection or punishment. It is about knowing that sharing a different perspective or acknowledging that something has gone wrong will not automatically lead to negative consequences.

Harvard professor Amy Edmondson explored this concept in her 1999 study examining the relationship between psychological safety and team learning behaviour, highlighting how an environment where employees can ask for help, discuss mistakes, and share ideas openly supports learning and collaboration.

Leaders play an important role in shaping this environment. Their responses to questions, disagreements, mistakes, and feedback send signals about whether speaking openly is genuinely encouraged. Over time, these everyday interactions influence how comfortable employees feel contributing their perspectives and raising concerns.

A friendly team environment does not automatically mean psychological safety exists. What matters is whether people feel able to be honest, express concerns and take interpersonal risks, even when doing so may be uncomfortable.

Signs of Psychological Safety and Its Absence

Psychological safety is reflected in the everyday behaviours and interactions within a team. While it may not always be immediately visible, the way employees participate in discussions, respond to feedback and approach their leaders can offer useful indications of whether they feel comfortable speaking openly.

In a psychologically safe workplace, employees are more likely to:

  • Speak up and ask questions: Team members feel comfortable seeking clarification, sharing suggestions, and raising concerns, even when their views differ from those of their leaders.
  • Disagree respectfully: Employees can question decisions, challenge existing practices and offer alternative perspectives without worrying that disagreement will affect how they are perceived.
  • Acknowledge mistakes: People are willing to admit when something has gone wrong, seek support and discuss what can be learned, rather than focusing only on avoiding blame.
  • Give and receive feedback: Conversations about performance, ideas, and areas of improvement can take place openly, with employees feeling that their perspectives will be considered.
  • Participate meaningfully: Contributions are not limited to a few individuals. Different voices are heard, and employees feel that their input has value.

The absence of psychological safety, on the other hand, may not always appear as visible conflict or dissatisfaction. Employees may continue to attend meetings, complete their responsibilities and maintain cordial relationships while choosing not to express what they really think. Some signs include:

  • Employees agreeing with decisions in meetings but raising objections privately afterwards.
  • Team members hesitating to ask questions or admit when they need help.
  • Mistakes being concealed or discussed only when they become unavoidable.
  • Employees withdrawing from conversations or becoming defensive when feedback is shared.
  • The same individuals consistently contributing while others remain quiet or disengaged.

A 2026 qualitative study of employees across different industries also highlighted fear of negative consequences, hierarchical distance, and a lack of feedback as factors that can discourage employees from speaking up. Their findings also highlighted emotional disengagement, where employees may stop contributing because they no longer expect their voices to make a difference. This is an important distinction: silence may not always come from fear; sometimes it reflects a loss of trust that speaking up will lead to anything meaningful.

For leaders, recognising these signs requires looking beyond whether employees participate in meetings or respond positively to questions. It means paying attention to whose perspectives are being heard, how disagreement is received and whether employees continue to contribute when conversations become uncomfortable. These everyday signals offer an important starting point for understanding the environment a leader is creating.

A leader in a suit sits at a round table with a yellow checkmark thought bubble indicating they think everything is fine, while surrounding employees have thought bubbles with a tangled scribble of stress and ellipses of unspoken concerns, illustrating a lack of psychological safety.

The Leader's Role in Creating Psychological Safety

Creating psychological safety requires more than encouraging employees to speak openly. Leaders need to demonstrate through their everyday actions that questions, disagreements, mistakes and feedback will be received constructively. Here are five ways they can contribute to a psychologically safe workplace.

1. Encourage Open Communication – 
Leaders can encourage open communication by actively inviting employees to share their views, asking for input before making decisions and making space for perspectives that differ from their own. However, inviting people to speak is only the starting point. How leaders respond matters just as much. Dismissing an idea, becoming defensive or reacting negatively to disagreement can discourage employees from participating in future conversations.

McKinsey’s 2021 research on psychological safety highlights the importance of consultative leadership, where leaders seek employee opinions, consider their perspectives and involve them in decisions that affect their work. These behaviours contribute to a positive team climate, an important foundation for psychological safety.

2. Respond Constructively to Mistakes
How leaders respond when something goes wrong can influence whether employees feel comfortable acknowledging mistakes or asking for help. If errors are met with blame or disproportionate criticism, employees may become more focused on protecting themselves than finding solutions.

Psychological safety does not mean overlooking mistakes or lowering performance expectations. It means approaching them as opportunities to understand what happened, identify gaps, and improve how work is done. Leaders can do this by asking questions, listening to different perspectives, and separating accountability from blame. The same applies when employees offer feedback to their leaders. Leaders who are willing to listen, reflect, and acknowledge their own shortcomings demonstrate that openness applies to everyone, regardless of position.

3. Build Trust Through Consistency
Trust develops through repeated interactions in which employees experience their leaders as approachable, fair and dependable. This could mean making time for regular check-ins, following through on commitments, maintaining confidentiality and responding to concerns without favouritism.

KoneÄŤná, Lisá and ÄŚiriková’s (2026) qualitative study identified emotional availability, responsiveness and consistency as important leadership qualities associated with psychological safety. Their findings highlight how employees’ experiences of their leaders in everyday interactions can influence their willingness to speak up.

4. Balance Support with Challenge
Psychological safety should not be mistaken for a workplace where everyone agrees or where employees are never challenged. Teams also need opportunities to question assumptions, explore unfamiliar ideas, and work towards higher standards.

McKinsey’s research offers an important distinction: supportive and consultative leadership help establish a positive team climate, while challenging leadership can further strengthen psychological safety when that foundation is already in place. Without adequate support and consultation, challenging employees may instead create anxiety.

Leaders therefore need to establish trust and ensure employees feel heard before encouraging them to stretch beyond familiar ways of working, take considered risks and question established practices. The aim is to create an environment where people feel both supported and appropriately challenged.

5. Follow Through on Feedback
Asking employees to share feedback creates an expectation that their input will be taken seriously. Not every suggestion can be implemented, and leaders may not always be able to resolve an issue immediately. However, acknowledging concerns, explaining decisions and communicating what action will be taken can help maintain trust.

KoneÄŤná and colleagues’ study also found that employees may stop speaking up when their suggestions are repeatedly ignored or fail to lead to meaningful change. This reinforces the importance of closing the feedback loop.

Leaders need to close this feedback loop. Employees should be able to see that their perspectives have been heard, considered and responded to, even when the outcome is not what they initially hoped for.

Turning Psychological Safety into Everyday Practice

Psychological safety is built through the everyday experiences employees have with their leaders. It is not enough to invite people to share their perspectives; leaders must also demonstrate that those perspectives will be heard, considered, and treated with respect. Ultimately, a psychologically safe workplace is one where employees can disagree, ask questions, acknowledge mistakes and challenge existing practices without fear of being dismissed or penalised. Creating such an environment requires consistency, openness and a willingness to learn, not just from employees but from leaders themselves. At Breath Beings, we work with organisations to develop leaders who can build trust, encourage open communication and create environments where people feel heard and valued. Explore our leadership development programmes to strengthen leadership capabilities and build more inclusive, psychologically safe workplaces.

Table of Content

Subscribe to our monthly DEIB newsletter

Explore Resources

Share this post

Other Posts

Intergenerational colleagues also operate on preconceived notions, assumptions of abilities, and stereotypes. Older employees are often disdainful of the way
, 5 mins read
Companies that prioritize inclusivity and foster a welcoming culture have a distinct advantage in attracting and retaining the best and
, 6 mins read
Gender-neutral language promotes inclusivity, creating room for those the values behind it to show up in action, whether it's how
, 6 mins read

Intellectual property rights

You are not permitted to use this Website for any purpose other than knowledge and understanding of Breath Beings products and services.

All content in all forms on this Website, including (but not limited to) blogs, data, photographs,illustrations, logos and information belong exclusively to Breath Beings, unless explicitly stated. You shall not modify, distribute, perform, link, display, edit, or in any way exploit any of the content in part or in whole. Any modification or use shall be made only with the express written consent of the Creative Director at Breath Beings Pvt Ltd (write to aruna@breathbeings.in). Any extraction of the intellectual property of Breath Beings Pvt Ltd from this Website is prohibited.

By using this Website, you agree that all of Breath Being’s trademarks,signature programmes, copyrights, logos, product and brand features, service names are trademarks and property of Breath Beings Pvt Ltd.

All content, including but not limited to the format, script, dialogues, titles, and presentation of games, acts, and theatre plays created by Breath Beings Pvt Ltd are protected by the copyright laws of India. These intellectual property rights are owned by Breath Beings Pvt Ltd and are an integral part of our product offerings.

No part of our games, acts, and plays, including the format, script, dialogues, titles, and presentation, may be reproduced, distributed, or transmitted in any form or by any means, including photocopying, recording, or other electronic or mechanical methods, without the prior written permission of Breath Beings Pvt Ltd.

Breath Beings Pvt Ltd reserves the right to enforce its intellectual property rights to the fullest extent of the law. All rights not expressly granted in this disclaimer are reserved.

For inquiries regarding the use or licensing of our copyrighted materials, please contact us at begin@breathbeings.in

Thank you for respecting our intellectual property rights.

Breath Beings – REGD. OFFICE:
No. 198, CMH Road, 2nd Floor, Indiranagar, Bangalore North,
Bangalore – 560038, Karnataka (IN)